Refugees from Myanmar Pose Dilemma

by N.S.Venkataraman

( September 11, 2017, Chennai, Sri Lanka Guardian) Around 2,70,000 Rohingya refugees are reported to have entered Bangladesh from Myanmar, in the wake of the ongoing violence in Myanmar’s Rakhine province that has triggered an exodus of refugees . Some of the refugees have entered India also. More number of refugees are reported to be waiting to cross over.

Justifiably, Bangladesh is highly concerned about this influx of refugees , since Bangladesh itself has dense population and is an economically weak developing country. Bangladesh is well justified in expecting that the United Nations and other countries should interfere in the matter and ensure that the crisis in Myanmar would be sorted out immediately. So far, Bangladesh has handled the refugee influx situation with compassion and understanding but it has to necessarily make a choice between compassion and national security now.

The illegal immigrants and refugee issues have been creating problems for several countries . United Nations Organisation which has a separate section dealing with the refugee problems could not do anything worthwhile to find a lasting solution for this global issue.

Refugee crisis in Europe :

A few months back when refugees started entering Europe in a big way from middle east countries and Africa , Europe was caught unaware with no strategy to face this grim issue. German Chancellor accepted the entry of refugees into Germany, saying that it would be a matter of compassion and human rights issue. With such tacid encouragement from German chancellor, more refugees started flowing in from different countries such as distant Afghanistan,. After entering into Germany , several of the refugees have now placed themselves in other European countries also. The entry of these refugees into Europe whose background and even nationality are not known in many cases and whose education and skill level are very poor compared to the European standards, Europe now has a huge problem on it’s shoulders, threatening to destabilize Europe and change the face of European life to some extent in the coming years apart from posing security threat. Social tension is already evident due to settlement of refugees in some pockets in Europe.

Anti immigrant policy in USA :

During the last Presidential election in USA, Donald Trump advocated an anti immigrant policy which received wide acceptance in USA and perhaps, this was the one big factor that catapulated Donald Trump to the post of US President. Now, he wants to construct a huge wall between USA and Mexico as a proof of his commitment to anti immigrant policy.

Sri Lankan refugees in India :

In Sri Lanka, at the time of the ethnic war between Sri Lankan government and the separatists, hundreds of Sri Lankans of Tamil origin left the country and reached India. They continue to stay in India for several years now , maintaining their refugee status and many of the Sri Lankan refugees in India born in the last few years have not seen Sri Lanka at all.

Tibetan refugees due to China’s oppressive action :

Of course, one cannot forget that thousands of Tibetan refugees left Tibet and entered India in the wake of the forced occupation of Tibet by China and now the Tibetan refugees have spread themselves around the world and are trying to integrate themselves into the mainstream of the countries to which they have migrated legally or illegally.

How long Canada’s refugee friendly policy?

Perhaps, Canada is the only country in the world today which is extending an almost open invitation to the migrants and refugees from across the world, calling it as it’s commitment to humanitarian and compassionate principles. As of now, Canada is able to adopt such policy as it is an under populated country with large land area and huge natural resources. However, even within Canada, there is emerging difference of opinion as to whether such receptive policies towards migrants and refugees should be continued to be adopted in Canada, as there are already indications that some of the migrants and refugees who have entered in recent times may have questionable background.

Whither Myanmar refugees in Bangladesh :

The human rights activists around the world, who are mostly arm chair critics and commentators from the gallery , argue that the influx of refugees and migrants from one country to the other due to oppression and unsecured conditions should be viewed as a humanitarian problem and it will be cruel to drive them back with least consideration for their pitiable conditions.

U N General Assembly which will convene on September,12 may adopt a motion condemning Myanmar’s actions for creating a situation that caused the exodus of Rohingya refugees. But, this will not help the cause of Bangladesh in tackling the present refugee issue, as most resolutions and recommendations of United Nations are not viewed seriously anymore by any country in the world.

The refugees from Myanmar pose a dilemma for the world conscience, as to whether Bangladesh should accept the refugees at the cost of it’s security. With no refugee problem having been solved conclusively in any part of the world, Myanmar refugees will remain as talking point for sometime for the global media, until the next refugee crisis would happen in any other part of the world.

Author: Sri Lanka Guardian

Sri Lanka Guardian has been providing breaking news & views for the progressive community since 2007. We are independent and non-profit.