Why Not Dr. Manmohan Singh Give Benefit of His Wisdom to Country Men?

Today, more than anyone else, Dr. Manmohan Singh has all the credentials and expertise to express his views and provide guidance and shape the thought process of the country.


by N.S.Venkataraman

( October 18, 2017, Chennai, Sri Lanka Guardian) The public life of Dr. Manmohan Singh, the former Indian Prime Minister, can be divided into three segments namely his pre Prime Minister days, Prime Minister days and post Prime Minister days.

Pre Prime Minister days :

Dr. Singh held many respectable positions in prestigious bodies like International Monetary fund, Governor of Reserve Bank of India etc. At that time, people did not know much about him and many thought that he was one amongst many officials.

When Mr. Narasimha Rao became the Prime Minister of India at a critical time when the country was facing severe financial crisis, he spotted Dr. Singh and appointed him as the Finance Minister. This decision of Mr. Rao caused huge surprise and even misgivings in some quarters ,as Dr. Singh until then had no real exposure to politics and political governance.

However, strongly backed, supported and guided by Mr. Rao and with his own knowledge base, Dr. Manmohan Singh was credited for taking the country out of the financial crisis and initiating the reforms. Gracefully, Mr. Rao allowed Dr. Singh to enjoy all the glory for himself. Obviously, that was the best of time in Dr. Manmohan Singh’s public life until then and later.

Prime Minister days :

To the surprise of everyone, Dr. Singh was chosen as the Prime Minister candidate by Ms. Sonia Gandhi, when she could not herself get the job inspite of her strong desire.

During the ten years of his Prime Ministership, Dr. Singh was gradually losing the shine which was accelerated during his second five year term and he practically lost all shine when he completed ten years as Prime Minister.

The country men felt that Dr. Singh was only an Yes Man as Prime Minister acting at the behest of the Congress President who took him for granted for all practical purposes. Her son Mr. Rahul Gandhi virtually insulted Dr. Singh on several occasions and this renowned economist pocketed all the insults.

Several of his ministers were corrupt and obviously Dr. Singh knew that but he felt weak and helpless in controlling them, which virtually brought Dr. Singh to ridicule as Prime Minister of India.

Even his pledged admirers were surprised, when he gave an impression to the country men that he would like to get a third term as the Prime Minister.

Post Prime Minister days :

After laying down his office as Prime Minister, it was thought by many that Dr. Singh would gain back his glory as renowned economist by taking an independent stand on various issues.

However, the discerning observers were surprised when Dr. Singh continued to walk behind Ms. Sonia Gandhi and Mr. Rahul Gandhi and belittling himself in the process. The congress party has really no need for him now and obviously nobody takes him seriously in the party anymore. He is being used by the party in the way it wants , with Dr. Singh merely submitting himself to the beck and call.

When Dr. Singh spoke very severely in the parliament against demonetization, it caused considerable surprise, as he was known as the mild mannered person who could not control his own corrupt ministers when he was the Prime Minister. The language he used in the parliament to condemn the demonetization step of Modi government was not in good taste and certainly not expected from Dr. Singh that the country know of. Some even suspected that he was reading the script given by his party leader.

Why not give his wisdom to the countrymen?

All said and done, there is no doubt that Dr. Singh is a knowledgeable and experienced economist of global standing. Politics is not his cup of tea anymore and he is wasting his precious time now , when he has the opportunity to regain his original shine as an economic expert, that he enjoyed before becoming the Prime Minister of India.

Today, Modi government is implementing far reaching economic reforms and restructuring of several systems prevailing for decades. There are severe critics as well as admirers for Modi government’s policies and programmes.

It appears that both the critics and the admirers have pre conceived political leanings and priorities. The country men are now looking for independent view from experts ,who can rise above personal prejudices and give their honest views.

Today, more than anyone else, Dr. Singh has all the credentials and expertise to express his views and provide guidance and shape the thought process of the country.

It is high time that Dr. Singh should quit politics and speak as an independent person not anymore walking behind political leaders, who do not in anyway measure up to him in terms of knowledge and expertise.

If Dr. Singh were to do this , perhaps, even Modi government will seek his counsel and the debate on economic reforms in the country will be led in the right direction.

Of course, by quitting politics and giving his valued views on various issues in an impartial manner with the expertise that, no doubt, Dr. Singh possesses he will undo the damage to his reputation that he brought on himself as Prime Minister and the history will remember him for his pre Prime Minister days and the post Prime Minister days.

Author: Sri Lanka Guardian

Sri Lanka Guardian has been providing breaking news & views for the progressive community since 2007. We are independent and non-profit.